The messages of the film touched me profoundly and I haven't been able to get it off my mind since. Two of the things that startled me the most were the concepts of perceived and planned obsolescence. Since the end of December last year, I have been convincing myself that I need to purchase a MacBook Pro even though my current laptop, while a little on the slow side, is still functioning fine. But the more websites and forums I browsed, the more I convinced myself that I needed the Mac until it consumed my every thought and my happiness rested on whether or not I was able to purchase the product. However, as the weeks dragged on and rumours and leaks about imminent release of the latest update never came into fruition, I began getting anxious. The Cat can testify that without even having purchased the product yet, just the concept of it being introduced to my life, was already causing me a lot more grief and frustration than satisfaction.
When I wrote about being less commercial and wasteful in the raising of our future children, I never realised just how necessary it was. Although I always preferred handmade toys sourced from organic, sustainable and fair trade materials, there was a part of me that also asked "What's the harm?" if a well-meaning family member bought our children a Tickle Me Elmo (but you don't need to be a passionate feminist to see exactly what is wrong with Bratz dolls and their slogan, "Don't theorise... accessorise!"). What chills me now is that the short film highlighted those devastating effects that makes me think I could never look at a plastic, mass-produced toy from the latest commercial franchise the same way again. I can hear the whisperings from family members about me being crazy already.
Although it sounds simple to choose organic, sustainable and fair trade, there's an ugly side to it as well. It seems to have become the latest trend, targeted towards wealthy individuals with money to spare and who wants to assuage their guilt without really doing anything about it. When I delved into making my own bath and body products mid last year, I came across many articles that revealed the loopholes around calling things "organic" and "natural" legally without it being actually 100% organic or natural. When it comes down to it, corporations don't have to disclose everything and sometimes a buzz word on a stamp or packaging designed in pale green is all it takes to get us to believe we've paid our dues for our ecological damage.
I also hope there to be more people who see handmade as an avenue for promoting environmental awareness and responsibility rather than as just a business opportunity, let along jump on this doing-good-but-not-really wave and charge a premium. I'm fortunate to have a job that pays me well and allows me enough leisure time to develop new craft hobbies. I wonder why, aside from the initial curiosity, I decided to sell my jewellery last year on Etsy at all. The profit I made considering the amount of time it took for me to make the jewellery, photograph it, write descriptions, answer emails and package and mail orders, was equivalent to minimum wage, and the people who avoid Etsy for their local chain jewellery store that sells a pair of earrings made from plastic beads for $2-3 would never consider purchasing handmade pieces for 10 times that price. If I could do it again, I would have investigated using my store to promote mindful consumerism and made bespoke pieces at cost price.




2 comments:
It's frustrating that those who want to contribute by purchasing (often more expensive) green and organic products cannot make sound purchasing choices when there are so few regulations governing the labelling/advertising of "green" products. It's just impossible for the average consumer to research a product's environmental footprint, or the working conditions in the countless factories from which all the crude materials were sourced. Worse yet, Etsy and other lovingly home-brewed products tend to have a higher impact on the environment than mass-produced equivalents. Unless we're making our craft materials from scratch (e.g. gathering own own sand from the beach as our natural source of silica, melting it with our own windmill-powered heat fun to form glass, adding colour and lampworking it into our own beads), the environmental footprint and number of third world factory workers exploited to make the craft materials remains more or less the same. Hand made only alleviates the exploitation of workers in the final stage of production, i.e. when the craft supplies reach the hands of the Etsy seller. Even then, any positive contribution of handmade is offset by the huge volumes of jet fuel and packaging needed to individually wrap and deliver these handmade goods to customers worldwide, preferably on something fast like US Priority mail to appease the Etsy customer. In comparison the fuel needed to deliver a large, efficiently-packed shipping container of mass-produced goods over a 2-3 month period by sea is miniscule.
I'm afraid that to make any difference at all, we have to target every stage of the corporation's production process, from the harvesting of natural resources all the way up to the shop front. We could cease dealing with the corporation altogether, and move to perfectly self-contained lifestyles where no money is involved, where we grow our own vegetables, make our own cheese, somehow make our own toothpaste and generate our own electricity. Or we could pressure our governments to put these corporations in check for once.
Word ;). I also think it's important and valuable to do what you can, even if it is a small difference at one stage of the production-consumption process. If we simply made the conscious decision to buy less, we've already made a difference, no matter how minuscule.
Post a Comment
I appreciate you taking the time to leave a comment. If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to ask. Check back for responses as I will often respond here.
Thank you for taking the time to visit About a Bun and I hope you enjoyed your stay!